{"id":27043,"date":"2021-08-07T13:32:22","date_gmt":"2021-08-07T17:32:22","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/?p=27043"},"modified":"2021-08-07T13:32:22","modified_gmt":"2021-08-07T17:32:22","slug":"houghton-wins-precedent-setting-lawsuit","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/houghton-wins-precedent-setting-lawsuit\/","title":{"rendered":"Houghton Wins Precedent-Setting Lawsuit"},"content":{"rendered":"<div class=\"pvc_clear\"><\/div>\n<p id=\"pvc_stats_27043\" class=\"pvc_stats all  \" data-element-id=\"27043\" style=\"\"><i class=\"pvc-stats-icon medium\" aria-hidden=\"true\"><svg xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" version=\"1.0\" viewBox=\"0 0 502 315\" preserveAspectRatio=\"xMidYMid meet\"><g transform=\"translate(0,332) scale(0.1,-0.1)\" fill=\"\" stroke=\"none\"><path d=\"M2394 3279 l-29 -30 -3 -207 c-2 -182 0 -211 15 -242 39 -76 157 -76 196 0 15 31 17 60 15 243 l-3 209 -33 29 c-26 23 -41 29 -80 29 -41 0 -53 -5 -78 -31z\"\/><path d=\"M3085 3251 c-45 -19 -58 -50 -96 -229 -47 -217 -49 -260 -13 -295 52 -53 146 -42 177 20 16 31 87 366 87 410 0 70 -86 122 -155 94z\"\/><path d=\"M1751 3234 c-13 -9 -29 -31 -37 -50 -12 -29 -10 -49 21 -204 19 -94 39 -189 45 -210 14 -50 54 -80 110 -80 34 0 48 6 76 34 21 21 34 44 34 59 0 14 -18 113 -40 219 -37 178 -43 195 -70 221 -36 32 -101 37 -139 11z\"\/><path d=\"M1163 3073 c-36 -7 -73 -59 -73 -102 0 -56 133 -378 171 -413 34 -32 83 -37 129 -13 70 36 67 87 -16 290 -86 209 -89 214 -129 231 -35 14 -42 15 -82 7z\"\/><path d=\"M3689 3066 c-15 -9 -33 -30 -42 -48 -48 -103 -147 -355 -147 -375 0 -98 131 -148 192 -74 13 15 57 108 97 206 80 196 84 226 37 273 -30 30 -99 39 -137 18z\"\/><path d=\"M583 2784 c-38 -19 -67 -74 -58 -113 9 -42 211 -354 242 -373 16 -10 45 -18 66 -18 51 0 107 52 107 100 0 39 -1 41 -124 234 -80 126 -108 162 -133 173 -41 17 -61 16 -100 -3z\"\/><path d=\"M4250 2784 c-14 -9 -74 -91 -133 -183 -95 -150 -107 -173 -107 -213 0 -55 33 -94 87 -104 67 -13 90 8 211 198 130 202 137 225 78 284 -27 27 -42 34 -72 34 -22 0 -50 -8 -64 -16z\"\/><path d=\"M2275 2693 c-553 -48 -1095 -270 -1585 -649 -135 -104 -459 -423 -483 -476 -23 -49 -22 -139 2 -186 73 -142 361 -457 571 -626 285 -228 642 -407 990 -497 242 -63 336 -73 660 -74 310 0 370 5 595 52 535 111 1045 392 1455 803 122 121 250 273 275 326 19 41 19 137 0 174 -41 79 -309 363 -465 492 -447 370 -946 591 -1479 653 -113 14 -422 18 -536 8z m395 -428 c171 -34 330 -124 456 -258 112 -119 167 -219 211 -378 27 -96 24 -300 -5 -401 -72 -255 -236 -447 -474 -557 -132 -62 -201 -76 -368 -76 -167 0 -236 14 -368 76 -213 98 -373 271 -451 485 -162 444 86 934 547 1084 153 49 292 57 452 25z m909 -232 c222 -123 408 -262 593 -441 76 -74 138 -139 138 -144 0 -16 -233 -242 -330 -319 -155 -123 -309 -223 -461 -299 l-81 -41 32 46 c18 26 49 83 70 128 143 306 141 649 -6 957 -25 52 -61 116 -79 142 l-34 47 45 -20 c26 -10 76 -36 113 -56z m-2057 25 c-40 -58 -105 -190 -130 -263 -110 -324 -59 -707 132 -981 25 -35 42 -64 37 -64 -19 0 -241 119 -326 174 -188 122 -406 314 -532 468 l-58 71 108 103 c185 178 428 349 672 473 66 33 121 60 123 61 2 0 -10 -19 -26 -42z\"\/><path d=\"M2375 1950 c-198 -44 -350 -190 -395 -379 -18 -76 -8 -221 19 -290 114 -284 457 -406 731 -260 98 52 188 154 231 260 27 69 37 214 19 290 -38 163 -166 304 -326 360 -67 23 -215 33 -279 19z\"\/><\/g><\/svg><\/i> <img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"16\" height=\"16\" alt=\"Loading\" src=\"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-content\/plugins\/page-views-count\/ajax-loader-2x.gif\" border=0 \/><\/p>\n<div class=\"pvc_clear\"><\/div>\n<p><img decoding=\"async\" class=\"alignright\" src=\"https:\/\/i.pinimg.com\/736x\/26\/ba\/81\/26ba81e069bff9ab2d969c5a673e056e--the-fool-jester.jpg\" alt=\"Ship of Fools\" width=\"300\">Both local media reported that after a lengthy court battle, former Collus CEO Ed Houghton (and former Acting CAO for Collingwood), was awarded costs for his legal expenses during the Saunderson Vindictive Judicial Inquiry (<a href=\"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/?s=svji\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">aka the SVJI<\/a>).&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>This decision has implications for any subsequent lawsuits should our petty, punishment-obsessed council decide to attempt to sue those participants who have never been charged with any criminal activity from the SVJI&#8217;s events. It also shows how much the SVJI cost those participants (and the town <em>aka the taxpayer<\/em> when it was forced to pay legal expenses for participants). And, of course, only the lawyers profited from the SVJI.<\/p>\n<p>I can only assume that, like with claims made to personal insurers, following this judgment the town&#8217;s and EPCOR&#8217;s insurance rates will go up. This means we \u2014 local taxpayers and electricity ratepayers \u2014 will pay for the increase. The SVJI has already cost us more than $10 million since 2015 and continues to drain our money \u2014 with the <a href=\"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/will-madigan-pay-for-inquiry-costs\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">mayor&#8217;s and council&#8217;s blessing and active support<\/a>, of course.<\/p>\n<p>As noted on <a href=\"https:\/\/www.collingwoodtoday.ca\/local-news\/insurance-group-ordered-to-cover-most-of-houghtons-legal-fees-from-inquiry-4192921\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">CollingwoodToday<\/a>:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>An Ontario Superior Court judge has ordered an insurance group to pay a majority of the legal expenses Ed Houghton incurred while participating in the Collingwood Judicial Inquiry&#8230; In a ruling issued last month, Justice Mohan Sharma ordered the Municipal Electric Association Reciprocal Insurance Exchange (MEARIE) to pay $690,000 total to Epcor and Ed Houghton to settle the lawsuit filed to recover the legal costs&#8230; The ruling states the inquiry was an official proceeding under the Municipal Act, and while it was not solely against Houghton, it involved him and his work enough to warrant coverage.&nbsp;<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>(It&#8217;s worth reading the comments from readers below the story, too)<\/p>\n<p>The <a href=\"https:\/\/www.canlii.org\/en\/on\/onsc\/doc\/2021\/2021onsc5033\/2021onsc5033.html?searchUrlHash=AAAAAQALQ29sbGluZ3dvb2QAAAAAAQ&amp;resultIndex=10&amp;utm_source=collingwoodtoday.ca&amp;utm_campaign=collingwoodtoday.ca&amp;utm_medium=referral\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">decision from the Ontario Superior Court of Justice<\/a> is a rather complex legal document, but it makes some salient points relevant to council&#8217;s eagerness to pay more money to Mayor Saunderson&#8217;s and Councillor Hamlin&#8217;s former employers (deliberately ignoring <a href=\"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/why-are-councils-conflicts-of-interest-being-ignored\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">a conflict of interest in violation of the recommendations of the SVJI<\/a> and sole-sourced, of course), including (emphasis added):<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>The principles for interpreting insurance policies, and in particular exclusion clauses, are well-established. The policy should be interpreted to promote a reasonable commercial result; <strong>provisions granting coverage ought to be construed broadly; provisions excluding coverage ought to be construed narrowly; in the case of ambiguity, the interpretation most favourable to the insured should be adopted; and even a clear and unambiguous clause should not be given effect if to do so would nullify the coverage provided by the policy.<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>In addition, the court must strive to interpret the contract according to \u201cthe whole of the contract and any relevant surrounding circumstances\u201d in a way that \u201cpromotes the true intent and reasonable expectations of the parties at the time of entry into the contract\u201d and avoids \u201ceither a windfall to the insurer or an unanticipated recovery to the insured\u201d:&nbsp;MacDonald v. Chicago Title Insurance,&nbsp;2015 ONCA 842,&nbsp;127 O.R. (3d) 663, at para.&nbsp;66,&nbsp;per&nbsp;Hourigan J.A.\u201d<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>This decision will likely come back into play should the mayor&#8217;s former employers (who he voted to hire without declaring his previous employment with them) recommend future lawsuits. In that case, former town councillors and staff have the decision as a precedent, and will likely move to have the town&#8217;s insurance cover their costs and any claims made against them (coverage for former members was extended in the recent <a href=\"https:\/\/collingwood.civicweb.net\/document\/72550\/C2021-07%20Enactment%20of%20Indemnification%20By-law.pdf?handle=C0F1DFE258584E25A291B1648E7C396F\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">indemnification bylaw<\/a> council passed to make sure it was <a href=\"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/saundersons-job-killing-icbl-continued\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">protected from lawsuits by developers<\/a> after they passed their job-growth-and-revenue-killing ICBL in response to their <a href=\"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/?s=water+%22crisis%22\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">self-created water &#8220;crisis&#8221;<\/a>).<\/p>\n<p>In essence, in any lawsuit, the town will be suing itself for money: taxpayers will pay for it all and only the mayor&#8217;s former employer will walk away with any money. Funny how he managed that one, eh?<\/p>\n<p>These comments in the decision are also relevant (emphasis added):<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>[78] The applicants further rely on the Conduct Letter issued by the Inquiry which said the Inquiry might make findings of misconduct against Mr. Houghton.&nbsp; The fact that Mr. Houghton was given standing at the Inquiry supports the conclusion that Mr. Houghton\u2019s legal expenses were \u201cincurred in defence of a proceeding that was brought against him \u2013 <strong>even though he was not specifically and publicly named in the proceeding.<\/strong>\u201d&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>[86]&nbsp; Even if I were to accept that the Policy were limited to criminal and quasi-criminal proceedings as MEARIE suggests, the extensive scope of procedural fairness afforded to Mr. Houghton during the Inquiry was similar to that afforded to a litigant in a criminal or quasi-criminal proceeding.&nbsp; For example, Associate Chief Justice Marrocco provided Mr. Houghton with full procedural rights including advance notice of documents proposed to be entered and statements of anticipated evidence, a seat at counsel table, the opportunity to suggest witnesses, the opportunity to cross-examine witnesses on matters that bear on the subject matter of the Inquiry and are relevant to Mr. Houghton\u2019s interests, and the opportunity to make closing submissions.&nbsp; <strong>This further supports the conclusion that the Inquiry was a type of proceeding to which the Policy applied.<\/strong><\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>The story was also in the weekly flyer wrapper (<a href=\"https:\/\/www.simcoe.com\/news-story\/10448397-insurance-co-op-must-pay-former-collingwood-utility-president-s-legal-bill-judge\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">aka the Collingwood Connection<\/a>) and included this bit of erroneous codswallop:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>The inquiry found that former mayor Sandra Cooper\u2019s brother, Paul Bonwick, made commissions on both deals, and that Houghton\u2019s relationship with Bonwick provided an unfair advantage to the companies that the mayor\u2019s brother was working for.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>Bonwick did NOT receive a commission on the Collus sale. He was paid a monthly retainer by PowerStream. And in neither procedure was he employed by or paid by the Town of Collingwood. Even though it&#8217;s local media, we should expect accuracy and facts.<\/p>\n<p>Lawyers \u2014 particularly those at Mayor Saunderson&#8217;s and Councillor Hamlin&#8217;s previous firms \u2014 continue to get richer thanks to this council&#8217;s continued lavish spending on the SVJI. The town is neglected and falls apart and taxpayers continue to suffer this council&#8217;s egregious fiscal mismanagement.<\/p>\n<p>Collingwood deserves better.<\/p>\n<p><strong>~~~~~<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>The woodcut above is from the 1494 book, <em>The Ship of Fools<\/em>. Seems an appropriate work to quote when writing about our council and much of it appears remarkably relevant to their ineptness, even more than 500 years later. Chapter 71, from which the woodcut is taken, is titled &#8220;<em>Quarreling and Going to Court.<\/em>&#8221; The following is from that chapter:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>Now of that fool I would report<br \/>\nWho always wants to go to court,<br \/>\nAnd amicably end no suit<br \/>\nBefore he&#8217;s had a hot dispute&#8230;<\/p>\n<p>The judge, attorney \u2014 all the group<br \/>\nOf jurists feed from clients&#8217; dish<br \/>\nAnd win a handsome mess of fish;<br \/>\nDelay, protraction is their aim,<br \/>\n&#8216;Tis thus they trap and catch their game:<\/p>\n<p>Small cases e&#8217;en like big ones look,<br \/>\nA trickle&#8217;s made into a brook,<br \/>\nA foreign speaker must be brought,<br \/>\nImported here from far-off port,<br \/>\nThat he may well pervert the case,<br \/>\nAnd cheat the judges to their face&#8230;<br \/>\nSo many hearings there must be,<br \/>\nSo that there&#8217;ll be an ample fee,<br \/>\nAnd greater sums red tape will take,<br \/>\nThan all the sums we have at stake.<\/p>\n<p>The money won in lawsuits will,<br \/>\nOfttimes not pay your parsley bill.<br \/>\nThey think that truth can never see<br \/>\nWhen suits are lengthened endlessly.<br \/>\nThe man who&#8217;d rather sue than eat<br \/>\nShould have some nettles on his seat.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>From <em>The Ship of Fools<\/em> by Sebastian Brant, translated by Prof. Edwin Zeydel, Dover Books, 1962. The original has 112 chapters and 114 woodcuts.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<div class=\"pvc_clear\"><\/div>\n<p id=\"pvc_stats_27043\" class=\"pvc_stats all  \" data-element-id=\"27043\" style=\"\"><i class=\"pvc-stats-icon medium\" aria-hidden=\"true\"><svg xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" version=\"1.0\" viewBox=\"0 0 502 315\" preserveAspectRatio=\"xMidYMid meet\"><g transform=\"translate(0,332) scale(0.1,-0.1)\" fill=\"\" stroke=\"none\"><path d=\"M2394 3279 l-29 -30 -3 -207 c-2 -182 0 -211 15 -242 39 -76 157 -76 196 0 15 31 17 60 15 243 l-3 209 -33 29 c-26 23 -41 29 -80 29 -41 0 -53 -5 -78 -31z\"\/><path d=\"M3085 3251 c-45 -19 -58 -50 -96 -229 -47 -217 -49 -260 -13 -295 52 -53 146 -42 177 20 16 31 87 366 87 410 0 70 -86 122 -155 94z\"\/><path d=\"M1751 3234 c-13 -9 -29 -31 -37 -50 -12 -29 -10 -49 21 -204 19 -94 39 -189 45 -210 14 -50 54 -80 110 -80 34 0 48 6 76 34 21 21 34 44 34 59 0 14 -18 113 -40 219 -37 178 -43 195 -70 221 -36 32 -101 37 -139 11z\"\/><path d=\"M1163 3073 c-36 -7 -73 -59 -73 -102 0 -56 133 -378 171 -413 34 -32 83 -37 129 -13 70 36 67 87 -16 290 -86 209 -89 214 -129 231 -35 14 -42 15 -82 7z\"\/><path d=\"M3689 3066 c-15 -9 -33 -30 -42 -48 -48 -103 -147 -355 -147 -375 0 -98 131 -148 192 -74 13 15 57 108 97 206 80 196 84 226 37 273 -30 30 -99 39 -137 18z\"\/><path d=\"M583 2784 c-38 -19 -67 -74 -58 -113 9 -42 211 -354 242 -373 16 -10 45 -18 66 -18 51 0 107 52 107 100 0 39 -1 41 -124 234 -80 126 -108 162 -133 173 -41 17 -61 16 -100 -3z\"\/><path d=\"M4250 2784 c-14 -9 -74 -91 -133 -183 -95 -150 -107 -173 -107 -213 0 -55 33 -94 87 -104 67 -13 90 8 211 198 130 202 137 225 78 284 -27 27 -42 34 -72 34 -22 0 -50 -8 -64 -16z\"\/><path d=\"M2275 2693 c-553 -48 -1095 -270 -1585 -649 -135 -104 -459 -423 -483 -476 -23 -49 -22 -139 2 -186 73 -142 361 -457 571 -626 285 -228 642 -407 990 -497 242 -63 336 -73 660 -74 310 0 370 5 595 52 535 111 1045 392 1455 803 122 121 250 273 275 326 19 41 19 137 0 174 -41 79 -309 363 -465 492 -447 370 -946 591 -1479 653 -113 14 -422 18 -536 8z m395 -428 c171 -34 330 -124 456 -258 112 -119 167 -219 211 -378 27 -96 24 -300 -5 -401 -72 -255 -236 -447 -474 -557 -132 -62 -201 -76 -368 -76 -167 0 -236 14 -368 76 -213 98 -373 271 -451 485 -162 444 86 934 547 1084 153 49 292 57 452 25z m909 -232 c222 -123 408 -262 593 -441 76 -74 138 -139 138 -144 0 -16 -233 -242 -330 -319 -155 -123 -309 -223 -461 -299 l-81 -41 32 46 c18 26 49 83 70 128 143 306 141 649 -6 957 -25 52 -61 116 -79 142 l-34 47 45 -20 c26 -10 76 -36 113 -56z m-2057 25 c-40 -58 -105 -190 -130 -263 -110 -324 -59 -707 132 -981 25 -35 42 -64 37 -64 -19 0 -241 119 -326 174 -188 122 -406 314 -532 468 l-58 71 108 103 c185 178 428 349 672 473 66 33 121 60 123 61 2 0 -10 -19 -26 -42z\"\/><path d=\"M2375 1950 c-198 -44 -350 -190 -395 -379 -18 -76 -8 -221 19 -290 114 -284 457 -406 731 -260 98 52 188 154 231 260 27 69 37 214 19 290 -38 163 -166 304 -326 360 -67 23 -215 33 -279 19z\"\/><\/g><\/svg><\/i> <img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"16\" height=\"16\" alt=\"Loading\" src=\"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-content\/plugins\/page-views-count\/ajax-loader-2x.gif\" border=0 \/><\/p>\n<div class=\"pvc_clear\"><\/div>\n<p>Both local media reported that after a lengthy court battle, former Collus CEO Ed Houghton (and former Acting CAO for Collingwood), was awarded costs for his legal expenses during the Saunderson Vindictive Judicial Inquiry (aka the SVJI).&nbsp; This decision has implications for any subsequent lawsuits should our petty, punishment-obsessed council decide to attempt to sue those participants who have never been charged with any criminal activity from the SVJI&#8217;s events. It also shows how much the SVJI cost those participants (and the town aka the taxpayer when it was forced to pay legal expenses for participants). And, of course, only \u2026&#8230;&#8230; click below for more \u2193<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"_jetpack_newsletter_access":"","_jetpack_dont_email_post_to_subs":false,"_jetpack_newsletter_tier_id":0,"_jetpack_memberships_contains_paywalled_content":false,"_jetpack_hide_featured_image":false,"_jetpack_featured_image_duplicate_dismissed":0,"_jetpack_feature_clip_id":0,"_jetpack_memberships_contains_paid_content":false,"footnotes":"","jetpack_publicize_message":"","jetpack_publicize_feature_enabled":true,"jetpack_social_post_already_shared":true,"jetpack_social_options":{"image_generator_settings":{"template":"highway","default_image_id":0,"font":"","enabled":false},"version":2},"jetpack_post_was_ever_published":false},"categories":[4,1385,1607,924],"tags":[1591,745,1244,1608,1610,1609,980],"class_list":["post-27043","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-collingwood","category-conflicts-of-interest","category-legal-issues","category-saundersons-vindictive-judicial-inquiry","tag-blg","tag-epcor","tag-houghton","tag-lawsuit","tag-legal-costs","tag-precedent","tag-svji"],"a3_pvc":{"activated":true,"total_views":1257,"today_views":0},"jetpack_publicize_connections":[],"jetpack_sharing_enabled":true,"jetpack_likes_enabled":true,"jetpack-related-posts":[],"jetpack_featured_media_url":"","_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/27043","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=27043"}],"version-history":[{"count":14,"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/27043\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":27057,"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/27043\/revisions\/27057"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=27043"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=27043"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=27043"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}