{"id":8078,"date":"2014-03-11T09:47:38","date_gmt":"2014-03-11T13:47:38","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/?p=8078"},"modified":"2014-03-15T09:50:08","modified_gmt":"2014-03-15T13:50:08","slug":"whats-in-a-missing-word","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/whats-in-a-missing-word\/","title":{"rendered":"What&#8217;s in a missing word?"},"content":{"rendered":"<div class=\"pvc_clear\"><\/div>\n<p id=\"pvc_stats_8078\" class=\"pvc_stats all  \" data-element-id=\"8078\" style=\"\"><i class=\"pvc-stats-icon medium\" aria-hidden=\"true\"><svg xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" version=\"1.0\" viewBox=\"0 0 502 315\" preserveAspectRatio=\"xMidYMid meet\"><g transform=\"translate(0,332) scale(0.1,-0.1)\" fill=\"\" stroke=\"none\"><path d=\"M2394 3279 l-29 -30 -3 -207 c-2 -182 0 -211 15 -242 39 -76 157 -76 196 0 15 31 17 60 15 243 l-3 209 -33 29 c-26 23 -41 29 -80 29 -41 0 -53 -5 -78 -31z\"\/><path d=\"M3085 3251 c-45 -19 -58 -50 -96 -229 -47 -217 -49 -260 -13 -295 52 -53 146 -42 177 20 16 31 87 366 87 410 0 70 -86 122 -155 94z\"\/><path d=\"M1751 3234 c-13 -9 -29 -31 -37 -50 -12 -29 -10 -49 21 -204 19 -94 39 -189 45 -210 14 -50 54 -80 110 -80 34 0 48 6 76 34 21 21 34 44 34 59 0 14 -18 113 -40 219 -37 178 -43 195 -70 221 -36 32 -101 37 -139 11z\"\/><path d=\"M1163 3073 c-36 -7 -73 -59 -73 -102 0 -56 133 -378 171 -413 34 -32 83 -37 129 -13 70 36 67 87 -16 290 -86 209 -89 214 -129 231 -35 14 -42 15 -82 7z\"\/><path d=\"M3689 3066 c-15 -9 -33 -30 -42 -48 -48 -103 -147 -355 -147 -375 0 -98 131 -148 192 -74 13 15 57 108 97 206 80 196 84 226 37 273 -30 30 -99 39 -137 18z\"\/><path d=\"M583 2784 c-38 -19 -67 -74 -58 -113 9 -42 211 -354 242 -373 16 -10 45 -18 66 -18 51 0 107 52 107 100 0 39 -1 41 -124 234 -80 126 -108 162 -133 173 -41 17 -61 16 -100 -3z\"\/><path d=\"M4250 2784 c-14 -9 -74 -91 -133 -183 -95 -150 -107 -173 -107 -213 0 -55 33 -94 87 -104 67 -13 90 8 211 198 130 202 137 225 78 284 -27 27 -42 34 -72 34 -22 0 -50 -8 -64 -16z\"\/><path d=\"M2275 2693 c-553 -48 -1095 -270 -1585 -649 -135 -104 -459 -423 -483 -476 -23 -49 -22 -139 2 -186 73 -142 361 -457 571 -626 285 -228 642 -407 990 -497 242 -63 336 -73 660 -74 310 0 370 5 595 52 535 111 1045 392 1455 803 122 121 250 273 275 326 19 41 19 137 0 174 -41 79 -309 363 -465 492 -447 370 -946 591 -1479 653 -113 14 -422 18 -536 8z m395 -428 c171 -34 330 -124 456 -258 112 -119 167 -219 211 -378 27 -96 24 -300 -5 -401 -72 -255 -236 -447 -474 -557 -132 -62 -201 -76 -368 -76 -167 0 -236 14 -368 76 -213 98 -373 271 -451 485 -162 444 86 934 547 1084 153 49 292 57 452 25z m909 -232 c222 -123 408 -262 593 -441 76 -74 138 -139 138 -144 0 -16 -233 -242 -330 -319 -155 -123 -309 -223 -461 -299 l-81 -41 32 46 c18 26 49 83 70 128 143 306 141 649 -6 957 -25 52 -61 116 -79 142 l-34 47 45 -20 c26 -10 76 -36 113 -56z m-2057 25 c-40 -58 -105 -190 -130 -263 -110 -324 -59 -707 132 -981 25 -35 42 -64 37 -64 -19 0 -241 119 -326 174 -188 122 -406 314 -532 468 l-58 71 108 103 c185 178 428 349 672 473 66 33 121 60 123 61 2 0 -10 -19 -26 -42z\"\/><path d=\"M2375 1950 c-198 -44 -350 -190 -395 -379 -18 -76 -8 -221 19 -290 114 -284 457 -406 731 -260 98 52 188 154 231 260 27 69 37 214 19 290 -38 163 -166 304 -326 360 -67 23 -215 33 -279 19z\"\/><\/g><\/svg><\/i> <img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"16\" height=\"16\" alt=\"Loading\" src=\"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-content\/plugins\/page-views-count\/ajax-loader-2x.gif\" border=0 \/><\/p>\n<div class=\"pvc_clear\"><\/div>\n<p><a title=\"Wikipedia\" href=\"http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Horace\" target=\"_blank\"><img decoding=\"async\" class=\"alignright\" alt=\"Horace\" src=\"http:\/\/upload.wikimedia.org\/wikipedia\/commons\/thumb\/9\/95\/Quintus_Horatius_Flaccus.jpg\/200px-Quintus_Horatius_Flaccus.jpg\" width=\"300\" \/><\/a><strong>There&#8217;s a line in one of <a title=\"Wikipedia\" href=\"http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Epistles_(Horace)\" target=\"_blank\">Horace&#8217;s epistles<\/a><\/strong> that really caught my eye. In Latin it reads:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>Utque sacerdotis fugitiuus liba recuso,<br \/>\npane egeo iam mellitis potiore placentis<br \/>\n<strong>Horace: <a title=\"The Latin Library\" href=\"http:\/\/www.thelatinlibrary.com\/horace\/epist1.shtml\" target=\"_blank\">Epistles<\/a>, Book I, X<\/strong><\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>No, I can&#8217;t translate it.<span style=\"color: #ff0000;\">*<\/span> However, I was reading <a title=\"Amazon\" href=\"http:\/\/www.amazon.ca\/Epistles-Horace-D-Ferry\/dp\/0374528527\/ref=sr_1_sc_2?ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1394534810&amp;sr=8-2-spell&amp;keywords=dabid+ferry+horace+epistles\" target=\"_blank\">David Ferry&#8217;s 2001 translation<\/a> and he renders it like this:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>I&#8217;m like that slave who ran away because<br \/>\nThey fed him honey cakes and he longed for bread.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>That appealled to me both for my recent passion for making bread, but also for its philosophic &#8211; almost Buddhist &#8211; intent.<\/p>\n<p>Ferry gives us both the Latin and English, and I struggle to match the original with the English version. And in doing so, something about his translation bothered me. Something missing.<\/p>\n<p><a title=\"Wikipedia\" href=\"http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Epistles_(Horace)\" target=\"_blank\">Wikipedia<\/a> tells us that Horace&#8217;s (Quintus Horatius Flaccus) epistle X is about:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p><strong>The Advantages of Country Life<\/strong> &#8211; (Addressed to Aristius Fuscus, to whom Ode I.22 is also addressed).&nbsp;This epistle begins with Horace contrasting his own love of the country with his friend&#8217;s fondness for the town; then follows the praise of Nature; and finally the poet dwells on the superior happiness that moderate means and contentment afford, compared with riches and ambition.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>Fine. I understand: Horace is saying he prefers the plain life of the country, not the honey-cake life of the city. He doesn&#8217;t need the luxuries and the excesses to be content.<\/p>\n<p><a title=\"Poetry Foundation\" href=\"http:\/\/www.poetryfoundation.org\/bio\/david-ferry\" target=\"_blank\">Ferry<\/a> isn&#8217;t a literal translator: more of a poetic one. He&#8217;s been acclaimed for that, and criticized for it, too, but I like his work. Many English renditions of Latin poetry come across as stilted and forced, while I find Ferry&#8217;s work much smoother and reads more naturally (some call it &#8220;approachable&#8221;). (Read here how <a title=\"Intercapillary Space\" href=\"http:\/\/intercapillaryspace.blogspot.ca\/2006\/09\/horace-odes-edited-by-j-d-mcclatchy.html\" target=\"_blank\">other English-speaking poets<\/a> have variously tackled Horace)<\/p>\n<p>Still, one Latin word in the original stuck out as missing in translation: <em>sacerdotis<\/em>.<\/p>\n<p><!--more--><\/p>\n<p>Sacerdotal is an <a title=\"Merriam-Webster\" href=\"http:\/\/www.merriam-webster.com\/dictionary\/sacerdotal\" target=\"_blank\">English adjective<\/a> relating to priests and the priesthood; priestly. Merriam-Webster gives its origin as, of course, Latin:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p><strong>Origin of SACERDOTAL<\/strong><br \/>\nMiddle English, from Middle French, from Latin sacerdotalis, from sacerdot-, sacerdos priest, from sacer sacred + -dot-, -dos (akin to facere to make) \u2014 more at sacred, do.<br \/>\nFirst Known Use: 15th century.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>The <a title=\"Etymology online\" href=\"http:\/\/www.etymonline.com\/index.php?term=sacerdotal\" target=\"_blank\">Online Etymological Dictionary<\/a> gives us this:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p><strong>sacerdotal (adj.)&nbsp;<\/strong>c.1400, from Old French sacerdotal and directly from Latin sacerdotalis &#8220;of or pertaining to a priest,&#8221; from sacerdos (genitive sacerdotis) &#8220;priest,&#8221; literally &#8220;offerer of sacrifices,&#8221; from sacer &#8220;holy&#8221; (see sacred) + stem of dare &#8220;to give&#8221; (see date (n.1)).<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>Genitive means possessive, one of the forms of declensions of Latin nouns. But <em>priestly<\/em> slave? Or rather, slave of the priest(s)? Does that make sense? Apparently so. Others have included it.<\/p>\n<p><a title=\"Poetry in Translation\" href=\"http:\/\/www.poetryintranslation.com\/PITBR\/Latin\/Horacehome.htm\" target=\"_blank\">A.S. Kline<\/a> (2005) translates this line as:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>Seeing I flee sweet wafers like a priest\u2019s runaway<br \/>\nSlave: for it\u2019s bread I want now not honeyed cakes.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>And in this un-attributed translation on <a title=\"Authorama\" href=\"http:\/\/www.authorama.com\/works-of-horace-8.html\" target=\"_blank\">Authorama<\/a>, it comes out in prose as:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>And, like a priest\u2019s, fugitive slave I reject luscious wafers, I desire plain bread, which is more agreeable now than honied cakes.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>And this rather dated translation by <a title=\"About.com\" href=\"http:\/\/ancienthistory.about.com\/library\/bl\/bl_text_horace_ep1.htm\" target=\"_blank\">John Conington<\/a> renders it (without writing slave):<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>Like the priest&#8217;s runaway, I cannot eat<br \/>\nYour cakes, but pine for bread of wholesome wheat.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>And in another archaic translation at <a title=\"Archive.org\" href=\"http:\/\/archive.org\/stream\/satiresepistlesa00horauoft\/satiresepistlesa00horauoft_djvu.txt\" target=\"_blank\">Archive.org<\/a> it comes out:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>Like the priest&#8217;s runaway slave, I loathe<br \/>\nsweet wafers; &#8217;tis bread I want, and now prefer to<br \/>\nhoneyed cakes.&#8221;<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p><a title=\"Google Books\" href=\"http:\/\/books.google.ca\/books?id=6HEoAAAAYAAJ&amp;dq=horace+epistles&amp;source=gbs_navlinks_s\" target=\"_blank\">John Stockdale&#8217;s translation<\/a> from 1787 mentions the priest&#8217;s slave:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>Like some priest&#8217;s slave lately fled,<br \/>\nI spurn sweet cakes and long for bread.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>Is the reference to a priest&#8217;s&nbsp;slave salient to the translation? Most other translators seem to think so.<\/p>\n<p>Why is a priest&#8217;s slave different from any other slave? Is there some deeply-rooted Roman cultural reference here Horace&#8217;s original readers would have appreciated without need for explication?<\/p>\n<p>Is there a Roman tale about a runaway slave to which this refers? Or perhaps some commonly held belief that priests&#8217; slaves were more likely to run away? Were the slaves of priests fed more luxuriously than, say, household slaves? Horace must have mentioned the priestly connection for a reason. It seems important.<\/p>\n<p>So why would a translator choose to ignore that reference?<\/p>\n<p>Slavery was commonplace in Roman society. <a title=\"Wikipedia\" href=\"http:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Slavery_in_ancient_Rome\" target=\"_blank\">Wikipedia<\/a> tells us it:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>&#8230;played an important role in society and the economy. Besides manual labor, slaves performed many domestic services, and might be employed at highly skilled jobs and professions. Teachers, accountants, and physicians were often slaves. Greek slaves in particular might be highly educated. Unskilled slaves, or those condemned to slavery as punishment, worked on farms, in mines, and at mills. Their living conditions were brutal, and their lives short.<br \/>\nSlaves were considered property under Roman law and had no legal personhood. Unlike Roman citizens, they could be subjected to corporal punishment, sexual exploitation (prostitutes were often slaves), torture, and summary execution.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>There&#8217;s a fair bit about <a title=\"Ancient.eu\" href=\"http:\/\/www.ancient.eu.com\/article\/629\/\" target=\"_blank\">Roman slavery<\/a> online, but I can&#8217;t find anything significant about slavery in religious orders. <a title=\"Britannica\" href=\"https:\/\/www.britannica.com\/blackhistory\/article-24172\" target=\"_blank\">Britannica<\/a>&nbsp;tells us slaves were&#8230;<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>&#8230;employed by religious institutions in Babylonia, Rome, and elsewhere. Unless they were ultimately destined for sacrifice to the gods, temple slaves usually enjoyed a much easier life than other slaves. They served in occupations ranging from priestess to janitor.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>But beyond such general references to slavery, I have come up empty. I can also find no folktale or Roman story about a runaway priest&#8217;s slave, let alone one that refers to food as well.<\/p>\n<p>So I can&#8217;t say why Ferry opted to ignore the word. Just that it is like one of those little itches on your back you can&#8217;t quite reach to relieve, yet can&#8217;t quite ignore. Something just nags at me to say this word matters.<\/p>\n<p><strong>~~~~~<\/strong><br \/>\n<span style=\"color: #ff0000;\">*<\/span> Not yet anyway. I&#8217;ve just begun to learn Latin and my reading is at the See Dick, see Jane level. Or more properly at the Tiberis fluvius est; Tiberis et Nilus fluvii sunt level (from the &nbsp;<em>Lingua Latina<\/em> first book; Familia Romana). Maybe in a decade or two of study I will be able to tackle Horace.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<div class=\"pvc_clear\"><\/div>\n<p id=\"pvc_stats_8078\" class=\"pvc_stats all  \" data-element-id=\"8078\" style=\"\"><i class=\"pvc-stats-icon medium\" aria-hidden=\"true\"><svg xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" version=\"1.0\" viewBox=\"0 0 502 315\" preserveAspectRatio=\"xMidYMid meet\"><g transform=\"translate(0,332) scale(0.1,-0.1)\" fill=\"\" stroke=\"none\"><path d=\"M2394 3279 l-29 -30 -3 -207 c-2 -182 0 -211 15 -242 39 -76 157 -76 196 0 15 31 17 60 15 243 l-3 209 -33 29 c-26 23 -41 29 -80 29 -41 0 -53 -5 -78 -31z\"\/><path d=\"M3085 3251 c-45 -19 -58 -50 -96 -229 -47 -217 -49 -260 -13 -295 52 -53 146 -42 177 20 16 31 87 366 87 410 0 70 -86 122 -155 94z\"\/><path d=\"M1751 3234 c-13 -9 -29 -31 -37 -50 -12 -29 -10 -49 21 -204 19 -94 39 -189 45 -210 14 -50 54 -80 110 -80 34 0 48 6 76 34 21 21 34 44 34 59 0 14 -18 113 -40 219 -37 178 -43 195 -70 221 -36 32 -101 37 -139 11z\"\/><path d=\"M1163 3073 c-36 -7 -73 -59 -73 -102 0 -56 133 -378 171 -413 34 -32 83 -37 129 -13 70 36 67 87 -16 290 -86 209 -89 214 -129 231 -35 14 -42 15 -82 7z\"\/><path d=\"M3689 3066 c-15 -9 -33 -30 -42 -48 -48 -103 -147 -355 -147 -375 0 -98 131 -148 192 -74 13 15 57 108 97 206 80 196 84 226 37 273 -30 30 -99 39 -137 18z\"\/><path d=\"M583 2784 c-38 -19 -67 -74 -58 -113 9 -42 211 -354 242 -373 16 -10 45 -18 66 -18 51 0 107 52 107 100 0 39 -1 41 -124 234 -80 126 -108 162 -133 173 -41 17 -61 16 -100 -3z\"\/><path d=\"M4250 2784 c-14 -9 -74 -91 -133 -183 -95 -150 -107 -173 -107 -213 0 -55 33 -94 87 -104 67 -13 90 8 211 198 130 202 137 225 78 284 -27 27 -42 34 -72 34 -22 0 -50 -8 -64 -16z\"\/><path d=\"M2275 2693 c-553 -48 -1095 -270 -1585 -649 -135 -104 -459 -423 -483 -476 -23 -49 -22 -139 2 -186 73 -142 361 -457 571 -626 285 -228 642 -407 990 -497 242 -63 336 -73 660 -74 310 0 370 5 595 52 535 111 1045 392 1455 803 122 121 250 273 275 326 19 41 19 137 0 174 -41 79 -309 363 -465 492 -447 370 -946 591 -1479 653 -113 14 -422 18 -536 8z m395 -428 c171 -34 330 -124 456 -258 112 -119 167 -219 211 -378 27 -96 24 -300 -5 -401 -72 -255 -236 -447 -474 -557 -132 -62 -201 -76 -368 -76 -167 0 -236 14 -368 76 -213 98 -373 271 -451 485 -162 444 86 934 547 1084 153 49 292 57 452 25z m909 -232 c222 -123 408 -262 593 -441 76 -74 138 -139 138 -144 0 -16 -233 -242 -330 -319 -155 -123 -309 -223 -461 -299 l-81 -41 32 46 c18 26 49 83 70 128 143 306 141 649 -6 957 -25 52 -61 116 -79 142 l-34 47 45 -20 c26 -10 76 -36 113 -56z m-2057 25 c-40 -58 -105 -190 -130 -263 -110 -324 -59 -707 132 -981 25 -35 42 -64 37 -64 -19 0 -241 119 -326 174 -188 122 -406 314 -532 468 l-58 71 108 103 c185 178 428 349 672 473 66 33 121 60 123 61 2 0 -10 -19 -26 -42z\"\/><path d=\"M2375 1950 c-198 -44 -350 -190 -395 -379 -18 -76 -8 -221 19 -290 114 -284 457 -406 731 -260 98 52 188 154 231 260 27 69 37 214 19 290 -38 163 -166 304 -326 360 -67 23 -215 33 -279 19z\"\/><\/g><\/svg><\/i> <img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"16\" height=\"16\" alt=\"Loading\" src=\"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-content\/plugins\/page-views-count\/ajax-loader-2x.gif\" border=0 \/><\/p>\n<div class=\"pvc_clear\"><\/div>\n<p>There&#8217;s a line in one of Horace&#8217;s epistles that really caught my eye. In Latin it reads: Utque sacerdotis fugitiuus liba recuso, pane egeo iam mellitis potiore placentis Horace: Epistles, Book I, X No, I can&#8217;t translate it.* However, I was reading David Ferry&#8217;s 2001 translation and he renders it like this: I&#8217;m like that slave who ran away because They fed him honey cakes and he longed for bread. That appealled to me both for my recent passion for making bread, but also for its philosophic &#8211; almost Buddhist &#8211; intent. Ferry gives us both the Latin and English, \u2026&#8230;&#8230; click below for more \u2193<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"_jetpack_newsletter_access":"","_jetpack_dont_email_post_to_subs":false,"_jetpack_newsletter_tier_id":0,"_jetpack_memberships_contains_paywalled_content":false,"_jetpack_hide_featured_image":false,"_jetpack_featured_image_duplicate_dismissed":0,"_jetpack_feature_clip_id":0,"_jetpack_memberships_contains_paid_content":false,"footnotes":"","jetpack_publicize_message":"","jetpack_publicize_feature_enabled":true,"jetpack_social_post_already_shared":true,"jetpack_social_options":{"image_generator_settings":{"template":"highway","default_image_id":0,"font":"","enabled":false},"version":2},"jetpack_post_was_ever_published":false},"categories":[8,344,73,72],"tags":[620,75,345,147],"class_list":["post-8078","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-books","category-education-learning","category-language-grammar","category-books-by-the-bedside","tag-books","tag-language","tag-latin","tag-reading"],"a3_pvc":{"activated":true,"total_views":4450,"today_views":1},"jetpack_publicize_connections":[],"jetpack_sharing_enabled":true,"jetpack_likes_enabled":true,"jetpack-related-posts":[],"jetpack_featured_media_url":"","_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/8078","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=8078"}],"version-history":[{"count":13,"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/8078\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":8093,"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/8078\/revisions\/8093"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=8078"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=8078"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/ianchadwick.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=8078"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}